Is the Catholic Church a Christian church?

When we talk about God we often need to talk about him in parts. Because God is so big and our brains are so small, we need to be able to talk about him in manageable chunks. That is why we sometimes talk about the doctrine of the Trinity, or of Christ, of the church, of creation, and so on. However, because God is one and presents himself to us as a person, Jesus Christ, he is not reducible to those different parts; all these parts impact on and affect each other. You can’t change your doctrine about Jesus without it affecting your doctrine of the Trinity, for example. That is why when we learn and teach about God we study in a systematic way—so we can understand God best through an integrated and coherent system of truths, not isolated ideas.

Sometimes, as Evangelicals approaching Roman Catholicism, we look at various parts of Catholicism without considering how they relate to the whole Catholic system. For example, some might say Roman Catholics believe in the Trinity and the ancient creeds but that they have got the doctrine of Mary, Christ, salvation, the Bible and the church wrong at various key points. This atomization of Catholic teaching can lead us into saying things like, “The Roman Catholic Church is Trinitarian and creedal, and therefore more Christian than the Jehovah’s Witnesses or the Mormons”. One of the consequences of this error is to be less likely to be intentional in our evangelism of them. However, you cannot have a different teaching about Jesus and Mary and the church and salvation and the Bible without it profoundly affecting your teaching about the Trinity and your understanding of what the creeds mean.¹

Gregg Allison and Leonardo De Chirico have done some very helpful work in critiquing the Roman Catholic system from a biblical perspective.² In short, they suggest that the Roman Catholic system is best understood by the interaction of two key relationships. Firstly, there is the relationship of what they understand as the realms of Nature and of Grace. We might call them the physical world and the spiritual world. The second key relationship is the relationship between Christ and the Catholic Church. Catholics understand the Catholic Church to be the physical and spiritual continuation of Christ. The spiritual world is separated from the physical world and requires a mediator: Christ and the Catholic Church. You could represent it a bit like this:

In this system the spiritual world (the realm of Grace) needs the physical world (the realm of Nature) so that Grace can be expressed in Nature. Also, the physical world needs the spiritual world in order to be perfected so that Nature can be perfected by Grace. An example of this relationship can be clearly seen in the Roman Catholic sacrament of Holy Communion, where the physical elements—the bread and the wine (Nature)—are transformed by the spiritual realm (Grace). Subsequently, when a Roman Catholic (in the realm of Nature) receives the sacrament of Holy Communion (which is transformed by the priest to communicate Grace), he or she can have their Nature perfected by Grace and God’s Grace expressed in their Nature. If this system sounds quite philosophical, that’s because it relies more on Saint Augustine and his 5^th century Neo-Platonism and Thomas Aquinas and his 13^th century Aristotelianism than it does on the Bible.

The problem with this system is the way sin is minimized: “though marred by sin, tainted nature still possesses a capacity to receive, transmit and cooperate with grace”.³ Nature and Grace are the key elements, and sin is secondary. This results in a religion of progress from a tainted but still intrinsically good state to a better one. In contrast, the Bible presents creation (made good but thoroughly distorted by sin in every aspect) as requiring a supernatural act of God’s grace alone to re-create or regenerate it. This is most clearly seen in the way Jesus redeems fallen human nature by dying to sin and rising to new life. The biblical account of the relationship between creation and new creation is one of radical discontinuity: from death to life, from destruction to recreation (Gen 6:5; Ezek 11:19, 18:31; John 1:12-13, 3:3; 2 Cor 5:17; 1 Pet 1:3, 23; 2 Pet 3:7-10; Rev 21:1).

Also, the Roman Catholic religious system sees the Catholic Church as the continuation of Jesus in the world. One of the ways you can see this is again in their teaching on Holy Communion, where they argue that “the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity, of our Lord Jesus Christ, and therefore the whole Christ is truly, really, and substantially contained”.⁴ This teaching also impacts other doctrines where the Catholic Church takes on the characteristics of Jesus, like:

• salvation is through the Catholic Church
• the pope is the representative of Christ and infallible
• the Church has the authority to determine and interpret the Bible
• the Catholic Church is the continuation of Jesus, and is by definition the only true Church
• Because Grace is superior to Nature, there is a hierarchy within Jesus’ human and divine natures; therefore, as the continuation of Jesus, the Church has a hierarchy between clergy and laity
• Mary as mother of the Church plays a mediatorial role in salvation alongside Jesus by distributing Grace to Nature
• The Catholic Church becomes both the object of faith and also the one whose faithfulness saves those who believe in it.

There are a number of reasons why Evangelical churches have strongly and consistently resisted this idea that the church, however it is conceived of, is the continuation of Jesus in this world.

1. Jesus’ incarnation was a unique event. There is no suggestion in the New Testament that this event continues in the institution of the Roman Catholic Church or any other church.
2. Jesus is in heaven at God’s right hand and not present in this world in a natural sense (Acts 1:11; Eph 1:20-21; Heb 1:3, 8:1).
3. Following the Ascension, God’s Spirit is his chosen means of being present in this world until Jesus returns (John 14:16). The Roman Catholic teaching confuses the functions of the Spirit with the functions of Jesus, whom they understand to work in and through the Catholic Church.
4. Teaching that the institution of the Catholic Church equates to the presence of Christ in this world—which in reality, like all humanity, is corrupted by sin—distorts the divinity and the humanity of Jesus.
5. Salvation is through faith in Jesus alone and not faith in Jesus and the Church.
6. By teaching that Mary is the mother of the church, which is the continuation of Christ in the world, Mary becomes a co-mediator of God’s grace and an object of faith.

The Apostle Paul, when faced with Christians in Galatia turning from his teachings to those of the super-apostles, said not once but twice, “If anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to the one you received, let him be accursed” (Gal 1:8-9). When viewed as a system, the teaching of the Roman Catholic Church denies the seriousness of sin and the need for a new creation, distorts the humanity and divinity of Jesus in conflating Jesus with the institution of the Roman Catholic Church, assumes the work of the Holy Spirit on itself and elevates Mary as an idol. They present a different gospel to the one the Apostle Paul fought so hard to preserve in Galatia, and therefore should not be regarded as having accepted the true gospel, nor be considered as a Christian Church. Because of this our Catholic friends, neighbours and family are in grave danger and need our love, urgent prayers and evangelistic efforts!By understanding Roman Catholicism better as a system, we can avoid the pitfalls that can occur when we look at the parts in isolation. We become convinced that we need to be intentional and persistent in our evangelism to Catholics to present them with the biblical gospel. Finally, by understanding how Catholics think about God we can present that gospel in a way that makes sense to them.

1. For an example of how this works read my previous articles, ‘Do Catholics and Protestants believe in the same God?’ and ‘Do Catholics and Protestants believe in the same Trinity?’.↩

2. If you want to read more about this, Gregg Allison’s book, Roman Catholic Theology and Practice: An Evangelical Perspective is a great place to start.↩

3. G Allison, Roman Catholic Theology and Practice: An Evangelical Assessment, Crossway, Wheaton, 2014, p. 47.↩

4. Catechism of the Catholic Church, para. 1374. Italics original.↩